Does the choice of performance measure influence the evaluation of hedge funds?
نویسندگان
چکیده
The Sharpe ratio is adequate for evaluating investment funds when the returns of those funds are normally distributed and the investor intends to place all his risky assets into just one investment fund. Hedge fund returns differ significantly from a normal distribution. For this reason, other performance measures for hedge fund returns have been proposed in both the academic and practiceoriented literature. In conducting an empirical study based on return data of 2763 hedge funds, we compare the Sharpe ratio with 12 other performance measures. Despite significant deviations of hedge fund returns from a normal distribution, our comparison of the Sharpe ratio to the other performance measures results in virtually identical rank ordering across hedge funds. 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. JEL classification: D81; G10; G11; G29
منابع مشابه
The Choice of Performance Measure Does Influence the Evaluation of Hedge Funds∗
It is widely accepted that, when return distributions are non-normal, the use of the Sharpe ratio can lead to misleading conclusions. It is well documented that deviations of hedge fund return distributions from normality are statistically significant. The literature on performance evaluation that takes into account the non-normality of return distributions is a vast one. However, there is anot...
متن کاملThe performance evaluation of hedge funds: a comparison of different approaches using European data
The standard approach to the evaluation of funds assumes a normal return distribution and uses the variance as a measure of the funds risk. A few characteristics of hedge funds, such as the remuneration mechanism of the portfolio manager, make this assumption unacceptable and the traditional approach of Risk Adjusted Performance (RAP) must be revised before applying it to hedge funds. Some auth...
متن کاملOne-Size or Tailor-Made Performance Ratios for Ranking Hedge Funds
Eling and Schuhmacher (2007) compared the Sharpe ratio with other performance measures and found virtually identical rank ordering using hedge fund data. They conclude that the choice of performance measure has no critical influence on fund evaluation and that the Sharpe ratio is generally adequate for analyzing hedge funds. Nevertheless, their analysis does not include the class of tailor-made...
متن کاملHedge Fund Strategy Performance: Using Conditional Approaches
The search for methodologies that accurately measure performance and performance persistence continues to evolve. This is especially true for investment strategies such as hedge funds, which have been shown, in several instances, to not be normally distributed. In this article, we evaluate performance of hedge funds using conditional approaches and GMM. Unlike the Sharpe ratio or Jensen’s alpha...
متن کاملPerformance Characteristics of Hedge Funds and Commodity Funds : Natural Versus Spurious
It is well known that the pro forma performance of a sample of investment funds contains biases. These biases are documented in Brown, Goetzmann, Ibbotson and Ross (1992) using mutual funds as subjects. The organization structure of hedge funds, being private and often offshore vehicles, makes data collection a much more onerous task. This amplifies the impact of performance measurement biases....
متن کامل